Skip to content
Nathan Colquhoun
← Writing

The math of Mark Carney’s war machine

Watching Mark Carney turn Canada into a rearmed warfare state while working-class people in places like Sarnia choose between rent and groceries has been depressing.

Carney wants you to believe that dropping half a trillion dollars on German attack submarines, armoured vehicles, and NATO quotas is “national sovereignty.” It isn’t. It is a massive, state-guaranteed corporate bailout for defence contractors, paid for by the deliberate austerity of Canadian communities. We are being sold a narrative of global fear to justify starving our own neighbourhoods.

The Banker-to-Bunker Pipeline

Carney isn’t a grizzled military general. He’s a central banker, a former Goldman Sachs partner, and an ex-Brookfield asset manager. When private capital markets wobble, state-guaranteed defence contracts become the ultimate low-risk, high-yield asset class. Canada hit the NATO 2% of GDP target in 2025 by injecting over C$9 billion in immediate cash, years ahead of schedule.

Over the next decade, Ottawa is planning more than half a trillion dollars in total investment for defence procurement and infrastructure. To move that money faster, Carney created the Defence Investment Agency, a new bureaucratic machine designed to speed the flow of public funds into private hands. He put Doug Guzman — an ex-RBC and Goldman Sachs executive — in charge of it.

The result is a familiar racket: public tax dollars funnelled through state agencies into multi-decade contracts for weapons manufacturers, guaranteeing private profit while offloading all financial risk onto working-class taxpayers.

The Math: Submarines vs. Starvation

People get defensive about military spending because they’re afraid. Afraid of global instability, afraid of losing what little security they have left. The state preys on that fear. But look at the contrast between what Ottawa funds and the material reality on the ground. While Carney signs off on C$81.8 billion in direct, near-term military expansion, our social baseline is collapsing.

Housing affordability is at a generational crisis point. The wealth gap is widening, with the top 20% holding 65.7% of net worth while the bottom 40% hold just 3%. Over 24% of people in this country live in food-insecure households. There are still Canadians lining up at our food banks. That’s nearly a quarter of the population struggling to eat while the government advances a roughly C$100 billion lifetime cost for up to 12 German ThyssenKrupp submarines.

We are still losing people every year to the toxic drug supply. In Lambton County the numbers have been brutal for years. We are told there is no fiscal room for treatment beds or real housing supports, yet Ottawa finds nearly C$2 billion for Armoured Combat Support Vehicles built just down Highway 402 in London.

Here in Sarnia the pattern is the same one we see nationally, only closer to the bone. Politicians celebrate a single pipeline announcement like it is salvation. City budgets swell for police infrastructure while the systems that actually keep people alive remain underbuilt. The people keeping this place from unravelling are not in Ottawa. They are the ones running food programs, sitting with people in withdrawal, fighting for housing that actually gets built, and refusing to accept that managed decline is the best we can do.

The False Promise of “Sovereignty”

The state defines sovereignty as the capacity to project force and patrol trade routes. They use phrases like “protecting the Arctic” and “alliance burden-sharing” to manufacture a narrative of heroism that completely omits domestic poverty. True sovereignty is not a multi-billion-dollar radar array or a fleet of diesel-electric attack submarines. True sovereignty is the ability of a community to feed and house its own people without permission from a bank or a bureaucrat.

History is clear on what happens when a state prioritizes guns over butter for extended periods. From the Soviet Union to 17th-century Spain, the pattern is the same: resource diversion, fiscal strain, and civilian shortages. You can maintain a military posture for a while, but the underlying human base erodes.

Our future does not have to be written by the same financial class that wrote its past. But we have to stop accepting the polite fiction that enriching arms dealers makes any of us safer — especially when the people actually building Sarnia are the ones left to do it alone.

Originally published in The Sarnia Journal.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *