Skip to content
Nathan Colquhoun
← Writing

Why Sarnia needs a community miracle rather than a lottery win

Every Thursday I watch Sarnia stand still, rain or shine, waiting in line ups that pack downtown.

I watch hundreds of my neighbours wrap around the Legion for a $5 shot at a $2 million miracle. I also watch the early morning huddles at the bin store in Mitton Village, people waiting for the drop, hoping for a deal that makes the week’s math finally work. There is no shame in those lines. There is only a quiet, heavy exhaustion.

As the weeks go on, and the line ups grow I realize what I am not hearing. I'm not hearing live music from downtown. I'm not hearing the messy, beautiful noise of a city actually creating something. It is a strange diagnostic for Sarnia that it is easier to stand in a line every Thursday for a chance to win a jackpot than it is to hang out in a park every Thursday with our community to listen to music. Ray Oldenburg used to talk about third spaces, those great good places like pubs, parks and cafes where we gather to just be together. In Sarnia, we have traded those third spaces for transactional ones. We are standing in thin spaces where we are together in proximity but remain competitors for a single exit.

For twenty years, I have been obsessed with the idea of staying. I have believed that the most radical thing we can do in a place like Sarnia is to root ourselves here and socialize our risks together at kitchen tables, cafes, breweries and green spaces. But right now, it feels like we are clutching a ticket and praying for a way out of the struggle. Mark Fisher once said it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism. In Sarnia, it feels easier to imagine a $2 million win than it does to imagine a city where we can actually afford to live and enjoy it.

It feels like our municipal leaders are completely tone deaf to this struggle. While we are scrambling for bin deals, they are focused on $230 million building projects, stopping housing developments and manufactured rage at anyone with a creative idea.

Hell, there is even a $1.5 million price tag on my head right now because I asked questions about how our police service is governed and the conflicts of interest that exist within that system. It is the same type of thinking that prioritizes a fortress over a community. They are protecting a narrative of control while the actual cultural infrastructure of the city is left to rot.

We have been trained by a century of extraction to wait for a miracle from above. We have been taught that wealth is something that happens to us, like a new plant opening or a lucky draw, rather than something we build together.

I am dreaming of a city that chooses a different kind of gathering.

I am dreaming of a city that doesn't wait for a festival to be organized by someone else. I am dreaming of people flooding the parks this summer with picnics that have no entry fee. I am dreaming of us setting up house shows and art exhibits in our living rooms. I imagine us taking turns making meals for each other and filling our neighbourhoods with the smell of shared potlucks. I am dreaming of a city where the music is loud enough to remind us that we are still here.

A city is not a business to be managed or a population to be policed. It is a place where we belong to one another.

We do not need a miracle to be rich. We need a city where we are not all trying to escape at the same time. The miracle is just us finally deciding that we have stood in line long enough. It is time to start showing up for each other in the spaces we already have.

Originally published in The Sarnia Journal.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *