Guns for the People?

I took a stab at writing a manifesto, an attempt to describe a position in an ongoing debate whether experienced or hypothetical.
We believe people have a right to protect themselves.1We do not believe that organizations, systems, or institutions have that right.2

Guns are tools — not gods.3

They should be kept close, used rarely, and never pointed in the name of profit, order, or pride.4

A gun in the hands of a scared woman is different than a gun in the hands of a scared state.5

We are not building armies.6

We are not interested in uniforms, badges, or codes that make you pull the trigger faster.

A person can be trusted.7

A system cannot.

We reject the idea that safety comes from force.

We reject the idea that violence can be outsourced to a few while the rest of us pretend we’re clean.8

We want fewer guns in the world.

But if they exist, they must belong to people — not power.9

No one should be forced to fight.

But no one should be punished for surviving.10

The people can carry.

The police cannot.

The difference is not the weapon — it’s the reason.11

When power has guns, it grows.

When people have guns, it endures.12


📚 Footnotes — The Long Line Behind These Ideas

  1. “people have a right to protect themselves”
    Frantz Fanon – The Wretched of the Earth; Angela Davis – “Are Prisons Obsolete?”; Mariame Kaba – Abolitionist essays on community protection.
  2. “systems or institutions do not”
    Michel Foucault – Discipline and Punish; David Graeber – The Utopia of Rules; James C. Scott – Seeing Like a State.
  3. “guns are tools — not gods”
    Wendell Berry – on tools as morally neutral; Robert Farrar Capon – The Supper of the Lamb; Simone Weil – on force as false transcendence.
  4. “never pointed in the name of profit, order, or pride”
    Ruth Wilson Gilmore – Golden Gulag; bell hooks – Killing Rage; Chris Hedges – War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning.
  5. “scared woman vs. scared state”
    Audre Lorde – Sister Outsider; Zora Neale Hurston; Saidiya Hartman – Scenes of Subjection.
  6. “we are not building armies”
    Leo Tolstoy – Christian anarchism; Dorothy Day – Catholic Worker Movement; Howard Zinn – A People’s History of the United States.
  7. “a person can be trusted. a system cannot.”
    Max Stirner – The Ego and Its Own; Elinor Ostrom – Governing the Commons; Ivan Illich – Deschooling Society.
  8. “violence can’t be outsourced”
    Hannah Arendt – On Violence; James Baldwin – “A Letter to My Nephew”; Fred Moten – The Undercommons.
  9. “fewer guns in the world…must belong to people”
    Black Panther Party – Ten-Point Program; Huey Newton – Revolutionary Suicide; Peter Kropotkin – Mutual Aid.
  10. “no one should be punished for surviving”
    Angela Davis – on criminalization of self-defense; Dean Spade – Mutual Aid; Adrienne Maree Brown – Emergent Strategy.
  11. “difference is not the weapon — it’s the reason”
    Simone Weil – The Iliad or The Poem of Force; Malcolm X – on the morality of self-defense; MLK – “Letter from Birmingham Jail”.
  12. “when power has guns, it grows. when people have guns, it endures.”
    Noam Chomsky – On Power and Ideology; Colin Ward – Anarchy in Action; Rebecca Solnit – A Paradise Built in Hell.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *